Where to get great ice cream

Krisch in Massapequa offers a variety of ice

Ed Betz, 2009

User rating:

Click to rate

In addition to many chain stores, Long Island is blessed with dozens of independent ice-cream parlors. These are some of the most popular.

--Compiled by Erica Marcus

User rating 3

Baci Gelato Food, Dairy products, Specialty, Sweets, Kids 591 Willis Ave. Williston Park The snow has melted, spring is only weeks away. Is it too soon to start ...
User rating 3

Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen $$ | Diner, Breakfast, Ice cream, Kids 2391 Montauk Hwy. Bridgehampton The Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen is great for an easygoing breakfast, lunch and dinner. ...
User rating 3

Bollinger's Family Restaurant $ | Diner, Breakfast, Ice cream, Soda fountain, Lunch, Sweets, Kids 282 Main St. Farmingdale Homemade ice cream is the main event here, with dozens of flavors turned into all ...
User rating 3

Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream $ | Ice cream, Soda fountain, Kids 75 Howells Rd. Bay Shore Coyle's, a Long Island staple since 1985, specializes in ice cream that is elaborate in ...
User rating 4

Coyle's $ | Ice cream, Dessert, Restaurant, Kids 509 Main St. Islip Before or after extra innings, slide into Coyle's, 509 Main St., Islip; 631-617- 5014. Waffle-cone ...
User rating 4

Five Pennies Creamery Shopping, Food, Sweets 11 N. Park Ave. Rockville Centre In addition to fine ice cream, Five Pennies Creamery in Rockville Centre turns out Coney ...
User rating 3

Gooseberry Grove Ice cream, Kids 12 E. Main St. Oyster Bay If you're intent on ice cream: Gooseberry Grove, a nostalgic scoop of a place for ...
User rating 4

Herrell’s Ice Cream $ | Ice cream, Dessert, Sweets, Kids 46L Gerard St. Huntington Rick and Cathy Meuser opened the doors less than two weeks ago to this Huntington ...
User rating 3

Hicksville Sweet Shop $ | Diner, Ice cream, Soda fountain, Kids 75 Broadway Hicksville Shop selling handmade ice cream, sauces and syrups as well as candies and molded chocolates. ...
User rating 2

Henry's Confectionary in Glen Cove $ | American, Sweets, Breakfast, Kids 8 Glen St. Glen Cove One of Long Island's real restaurant gems, Henry's has been serving Glen Cove residents since ...