The Trattoria review
532 North Country Rd. St. James, NY 11780-1424
The Trattoria description Placing Italian inspiration into contemporary American cooking, this sister venue of nearby Kitchen A Bistro ... More »
Related mediaThe Trattoria LI's 10 best Italian restaurants 25 fine dining restaurants to try 127 new restaurants on LI The 10 best dishes on LI in 2013 25 Cheap Eats to try on LI
The Trattoria is the Trattoria.
Steven Gallagher, chef at Kitchen A Trattoria, bought the celebrated St. James spot in November and renamed it. Now, the restaurant is all his -- and even better.
The look has stayed pretty much the same as it was under Eric Lomando, who still runs the vibrant Kitchen A Bistro in St. James and Orto in Miller Place. Black-and-white photos, including one of the house's ravioli, decorate the unpretentious dining room. The tablecloth-free style goes with Gallagher's "rustic Italian" fare.
He changes the menu daily. But the results invariably are the same. This is a creative, genuine, fairly priced destination, worth toasting with your prime BYO wine.
Nibble on the excellent bread, and add house-made, lemony ricotta, sun-dried tomato tapenade and marinated olives. Then, consider the three-course fixed-price approach, the chef's tasting menu, or the a la carte reverie. The basic advice is to sample as many antipasti, primi and secondi as you can.
Memorable openers: soulful ribollita, the traditional soup of leftover vegetables, here fresh and enriched with chicken; smooth butternut squash soup with almond crostini; savory, tomato-braised meatballs with polenta; attentively baked littleneck clams; an appetizing salad of roasted beets with fennel, arugula, ricotta salata and pistachios. Slightly overdone shrimp with fennel puree and green harissa; and overorchestrated port-balsamic glazed ribs trail them a bit. The still-life of roasted garlic and tangy Gorgonzola, served with toasts, is very flavorful company.
Gallagher's pastas are terrific, from the smoky-sweet spaghetti all'Amatriciana and superrich bucatini alla carbonara to hearty paccheri with a suckling-pig ragù, and delicate squash-and-apple ravioli with dates and sage brown butter. And veer Bolognese with either pappardelle in meat sauce or the light, five-layer lasagna. He also prepares a grand eggplant alla Parmigiana.
Hake swims in on a puree of parsnips with Brussels sprouts and chestnuts for a fine fish course. Ocean trout arrives on a delectable raft of red cabbage and beluga lentils. Braised cabbage and rye gnocchi boost the juicy loin of pork; potato puree and spinach, the tender roasted chicken. The flaky, vinous brasato of beef finds its complement with creamy polenta.
Flourless chocolate-almond cake, maple-mascarpone cheesecake, the apple or pear crostata, and a chocolate-vanilla, two-tier crème brûlée are superior desserts.
Reserve a table -- soon.