1079 Hicksville Rd. Seaford, NY 516-731-0015
Known by generations of Plainedge residents as “The Pizza Cove,” this pizzeria has always been dedicated to its neighborhood, with photos and memorabilia on the walls that nod to local sports, firefighters and famous figures born nearby (Steve Guttenberg, John Melendez). The main event is pizza, and whether it’s purchased to go or enjoyed in the adjoining dining room, the stream of customers who arrive with remarkable frequency may occasionally grab some spaghetti or ziti—but the cheese pie remains the always-lauded centerpiece.
Credit cards: Not Accepted