Magic Taco Corp. review

Location info

Magic Taco Corp. just opened in Islip Terrace

3321 Sunrise Hwy. Islip Terrace, NY 11752

User rating:

Magic Taco Corp. description There’s no question that Magic Taco Corp., located in Islip Terrace, is anything but your ... More »

Travel deals

Kimchee pancakes meet pupusas. And steamed Asian buns. And, some days, even octopus tacos. No question, Magic Taco Corp. is anything but your average taqueria. And don't even think of it as a Mexican restaurant.

This quirky new Islip Terrace spot is driven by two chefs: Steven Scalesse, the force behind Tulullah's in Bay Shore, and Devin Delgado, who cooked with Scalesse for years. Their brightly painted little shack has three tables inside and six picnic tables outdoors. Forget amenities -- there isn't even a public restroom, let alone proper dinnerware. But if you're equipped with taste buds, you'll be happy to eat their food out of foil tins using plastic utensils.

Casual though the place may be, it's not a fast-food joint. So order some house-fried nachos with lively lime-accented guacamole (for right away) and prepare to wait.

INTERACT: LI's 100 best restaurants | All-star chefs

MORE: Latest fine dining reviews | Cheap Eats

Here, you'll find that rare kitchen with respect for vegans and vegetarians. So a vegan black bean soup with marinated tofu and pickled red onion goes head-to-head with the house special version, laced with fried pork cracklings. And a nuanced vegan kale salad with cauliflower and almonds can truly compete with the dynamite pork and peanut salad.

You can get your tacos (or steamed buns, or whatever) with or without any of numerous proteins, sometimes including duck. For a savory surprise, try soft corn tortilla tacos with seared marinated tofu and scrambled eggs. One day, a daily special of Portuguese octopus with avocado and potatoes in a tomatillo vinaigrette proves sensational. So, too, do steamed Chinese buns with hoisin barbecue sauce and juicy seared flank steak (carne asada). The same buns, ordered with grilled jerk chicken, while very good, somehow aren't in the same league.

Rice flour kimchee pancakes with pickled vegetables are colorful, piquant -- and gluten-free. Somewhat dry pupusas (griddled corn and cheese masa cakes) are boosted by a topping of pickled vegetables, jalapeño and, as a protein, smoked Berkshire pork belly. But cracker-thin crisp quesadillas with grilled spiced shrimp turn up nearly empty inside.

For dessert, there are "cinnamon things" -- e.g., fried steamed buns, to be dipped in crema Mexicana, similar to crème fraîche. Better yet are crispy-fluffy banana pancakes, made with gluten-free rice flour, topped with bananas Foster jam. A highly unusual -- and successful -- finale.

advertisement | advertise on exploreli

Like us

advertisement | advertise on exploreli