Lobster rolls

Newsday/Rebecca Cooney

User rating:

Click to rate

Years ago, Long Islanders hankering for lobster rolls would have to drive almost as far as Montauk to get a fix. Now, though, the combo of cool lobster salad on a toasted hot dog bun is the darling of clam shacks and fish houses Islandwide. Some are made with the meat pulled from local lobsters, others with lobster meat brought in from Canada. Here are some favorites, from East Rockaway to the East End.

--Compiled by Joan Reminick

User rating 3

Artie's South Shore Fish and Grill Seafood 4257 Austin Blvd. Island Park Artie’s is a seafood restaurant with a difference. Not only does it share quarters with ...
Critic rating 2

Bostwick's Chowder House $$ | Seafood 277 Pantigo Rd. East Hampton The owners of the former Bostwick's on the Harbor have taken over the space that ...
User rating 2

Clam Bar $$ | Seafood, Restaurant Montauk Hwy. Amagansett This is as basic as it gets. Order at the counter and take a seat. ...
User rating 3

Duryea's Lobster Deck $$ | Seafood, Restaurant 65 Tuthill Rd. Montauk No-frills establishment consisting of a wooden deck overlooking Fort Pond Bay and a small kitchen ...
Critic rating 2

The Fishery $$ | Seafood 1 Main St. East Rockaway On the deck overlooking a boat basin off East Rockaway Inlet, sample some fine chowders, ...
Critic rating 2.5

H2O Seafood Grill $$$ | New American, Seafood 215 W. Main St. Smithtown Sophisticated seafood house with sushi bar. ...
User rating 3

Jordan Lobster Farms Seafood, American 1 Pettit Place Island Park Lobster wholesaler by the water in Island Park. ...
Critic rating 1

Legal Sea Foods $$$ | Restaurant, Seafood 630 Old Country Rd Garden City Legal makes a fine lobster roll from freshly shucked lobster and celery mayonnaise (although a ...
Critic rating 1

Legal Sea Foods - Huntington Station $$$ | Seafood, Restaurant, Chain restaurants 160 Walt Whitman Rd Huntington Station Legal makes a fine lobster roll from freshly shucked lobster and celery mayonnaise (although a ...
User rating 3

Lobster Roll Southside $$ | Seafood, Restaurant 1980 Montauk Hwy. Amagansett Very casual summer place, notable for its namesake roll. ...