Best pizza

Barry Sloan

User rating:

Click to rate

Looking for a great pie? You've come to the right place.

Sauce makes or breaks a slice of pizza. The crust, too. And the cheese, the spices, the toppings. It's all a matter of pizza palate preference, and everyone's is different.

Thousands of ExploreLI.com readers sent us their favorite places for pizza on Long Island. We compiled the results for the top 10 spots for a slice of pizza on the Island, below.

User rating 3

Aegean Pizza Pizza, Italian 5801 Sunrise Hwy Holbrook Aegean Pizza has been serving Long Island's pizza needs for more than thirty years. ...
User rating 2

Aegean II $ | Pizza, Italian 61A Route 111 Smithtown Aegean II has been serving Long Island's pizza needs since 1974. Both were included in ...
User rating 3

Ancona $ | Pizza, Italian 200 Rockaway Ave. Valley Stream "All around delicious! Crust, sauce, toppings, cheese! There is a line out of the door ...
User rating 4

Colosseo Italian, Pizza 1049 Route 112 Port Jefferson Station "It's simple and honest, the way pizza should be," says John of South Setauket. ...
User rating 3

Emilio's (Commack) $$ | Italian, Pizza, Pasta 2201 Jericho Tpke. Commack As all neighborhoods tend to, people in this part of Commack will often gush about ...
User rating 3

Gino's Restaurant and Pizzeria $$ | Italian, Pizza, Pasta 16 W Park Ave. Long Beach With the feel that recalls an earlier era when a pizzeria was more of a ...
User rating 4

Little Vincent's Pizza Pizza, Italian 329 New York Ave. Huntington "Debated ordering a pie from Greenwich Village, jumping on a train from Penn station to ...
User rating 3

Little Vincent's Pizza $$ | Italian, Pizza 324 Smithtown Blvd. Lake Ronkonkoma Unlike the smaller Huntington location, this lakeside outpost of the Little Vincent’s restaurant family does ...
User rating 3

Pappalardo's $ | Italian, Pizza 1079 Hicksville Rd. Seaford Known by generations of Plainedge residents as “The Pizza Cove,” this pizzeria has always been ...
User rating 3

Umberto's of New Hyde Park $$ | Italian, Pizza, Chain restaurants 633 Jericho Turnpike New Hyde Park One of the quickest ways to spot an Umberto’s is to look for a restaurant ...